Skip to content

Commit 8be0b36

Browse files
committed
Auto merge of rust-lang#13344 - lukaslueg:issue13339, r=Alexendoo
Expand missing_transmute_annotations docs Fixes rust-lang#13339 changelog: [`missing_transmute_annotations `]: Expand docs, raison d'être
2 parents 78bdd45 + 7d2e6eb commit 8be0b36

File tree

1 file changed

+26
-6
lines changed
  • clippy_lints/src/transmute

1 file changed

+26
-6
lines changed

clippy_lints/src/transmute/mod.rs

+26-6
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -527,24 +527,44 @@ declare_clippy_lint! {
527527
/// Checks if transmute calls have all generics specified.
528528
///
529529
/// ### Why is this bad?
530-
/// If not set, some unexpected output type could be retrieved instead of the expected one,
531-
/// potentially leading to invalid code.
530+
/// If not, one or more unexpected types could be used during `transmute()`, potentially leading
531+
/// to Undefined Behavior or other problems.
532532
///
533-
/// This is particularly dangerous in case a seemingly innocent/unrelated change can cause type
534-
/// inference to start inferring a different type. E.g. the transmute is the tail expression of
535-
/// an `if` branch, and a different branches type changes, causing the transmute to silently
536-
/// have a different type, instead of a proper error.
533+
/// This is particularly dangerous in case a seemingly innocent/unrelated change causes type
534+
/// inference to result in a different type. For example, if `transmute()` is the tail
535+
/// expression of an `if`-branch, and the `else`-branch type changes, the compiler may silently
536+
/// infer a different type to be returned by `transmute()`. That is because the compiler is
537+
/// free to change the inference of a type as long as that inference is technically correct,
538+
/// regardless of the programmer's unknown expectation.
539+
///
540+
/// Both type-parameters, the input- and the output-type, to any `transmute()` should
541+
/// be given explicitly: Setting the input-type explicitly avoids confusion about what the
542+
/// argument's type actually is. Setting the output-type explicitly avoids type-inference
543+
/// to infer a technically correct yet unexpected type.
537544
///
538545
/// ### Example
539546
/// ```no_run
540547
/// # unsafe {
548+
/// // Avoid "naked" calls to `transmute()`!
541549
/// let x: i32 = std::mem::transmute([1u16, 2u16]);
550+
///
551+
/// // `first_answers` is intended to transmute a slice of bool to a slice of u8.
552+
/// // But the programmer forgot to index the first element of the outer slice,
553+
/// // so we are actually transmuting from "pointers to slices" instead of
554+
/// // transmuting from "a slice of bool", causing a nonsensical result.
555+
/// let the_answers: &[&[bool]] = &[&[true, false, true]];
556+
/// let first_answers: &[u8] = std::mem::transmute(the_answers);
542557
/// # }
543558
/// ```
544559
/// Use instead:
545560
/// ```no_run
546561
/// # unsafe {
547562
/// let x = std::mem::transmute::<[u16; 2], i32>([1u16, 2u16]);
563+
///
564+
/// // The explicit type parameters on `transmute()` makes the intention clear,
565+
/// // and cause a type-error if the actual types don't match our expectation.
566+
/// let the_answers: &[&[bool]] = &[&[true, false, true]];
567+
/// let first_answers: &[u8] = std::mem::transmute::<&[bool], &[u8]>(the_answers[0]);
548568
/// # }
549569
/// ```
550570
#[clippy::version = "1.79.0"]

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)